Menu

Need training at your office? Request a quote for custom training.

Home / Adobe Acrobat / Adobe FrameMaker: Importing PDF Comments (Part IV in the Editing Series)

Adobe FrameMaker: Importing PDF Comments (Part IV in the Editing Series)

By Barb Binder

“We have engineers who like to do their own editing. Can I export the text out of FrameMaker into Word so that they can edit their own documents?” This was a question posed by a student in one of my Advanced Adobe FrameMaker online classes.

The immediate answer is that yes, one can use File > Save as to save a FrameMaker file in Rich Text Format (.rtf), which can be opened in Word, but it’s really a “NO! You don’t want to do that!”. Once the file heads back to Word for editing, it will have to be imported back in, and will require a fair amount of clean-up to get it back to where it was. I can’t stand entering in corrections, but I’d rather do enter than have to re-import the corrected Word file and basically start the layout over.

The better solution for FrameMaker 9 and later is to incorporate Adobe Acrobat and/or Adobe Reader in to the workflow. Acrobat has had commenting tools for years, and they can even be used in the free Adobe Reader, if the file is prepared correctly. Using the PDF Commenting tools, the engineers can enter all their own corrections, and then e-mail the file back to my student. He can then open his FrameMaker document (or book), and import the comments back in. Once they have been imported, he can then use FrameMaker’s Track Text Edits toolbar to accept and reject the changes. Wow!

Here’s how it works:

  1. Open a FrameMaker document or book using FrameMaker 9 or FrameMaker 10.
  2. Create the PDF in Adobe FrameMaker:
    1. File > Save as PDF
      Adobe FrameMaker: Save as PDF opens the PDF Setup dialog box.
    2. Click the “Generate for review only” checkbox to generate a tagged PDF, along with your other favorite PDF options.
    3. Click Set.
  3. E-mail the file to one or more editors.
  4. Edit the PDF with the Commenting tools.
    1. Instruct the editors to open the PDF in Adobe Reader or Adobe Acrobat.
    2. In Acrobat 9 and earlier, choose Tools > Comment & Markup > Show Comment & Markup Toolbar.
      Adobe Acrobat/Adobe Reader: Comment & Markup toolbar
      In Acrobat X, choose View > Comment > Annotations.
      Acrobat 10: View | Comment | Annotations
      (In Acrobat, the toolbar will always open. In Reader, in my experience, the toolbar will not open unless you open the PDF in Adobe Acrobat and select Enable for Commenting and Analysis in Adobe Reader before sending the file to someone who only has free Acrobat Reader installed.)
    3. Enter the corrections using the following six mark-up tools: the Text Edits tools, specifically Insert text, Delete text, Replace text, plus Sticky notes, Underlined text and Highlighted text. Other mark-up is not imported. Here are examples of using the Insert text, Delete text, Replace text:
      Adobe Acrobat/Adobe Reader: Replacing text.
      Adobe Acrobat/Adobe Reader: Inserting text.
      Adobe Acrobat/Adobe Reader: Deleting text.
    4. Save and e-mail the PDF back to the FrameMaker user.
  5. Import the comments into Adobe FrameMaker 9 or 10.
    1. Open the Frame file (don’t change it while the PDF is out for review, or the comments may not show up in the correct positions).
    2. File > Import PDF Comments and follow the on-screen instructions to import the comments from the PDF.
      1. First, review the rules, and click OK:
        Adobe FrameMaker 10: File | Import | PDF Comments
      2. Pick the file to import from, and select the type of markup you’d like to import, and click Continue.
      3. Review the Import Summary to scan for errors. This one looks good, so click OK.
        Adobe FrameMaker: Import PDF Comments Report Summary
    3. Review the document and decide if you would like to accept or reject the proposed edits.
      Adobe FrameMaker: Comments imported back into FrameMaker

      1. Show the Track Text Edit toolbar. (For more details on how to use the toolbar, see Adobe FrameMaker: Track Text Edits (Part III in the Editing Series).)
        Adobe FrameMaker: Track Text Edits toolbar
      2. Using the Track Text Edits buttons, accept and reject the various changes.
        Adobe FrameMaker
        Adobe FrameMaker
        Adobe FrameMaker
      3. Wow!
        Adobe FrameMaker: all PDF markup was either accepted or rejected.

      NOTE: This article was previously published on blog.rockymountaintraining.com. It was revised to include FrameMaker 10 and Acrobat X and republished on 11/17/11.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

7 thoughts on “Adobe FrameMaker: Importing PDF Comments (Part IV in the Editing Series)

  1. Hello Mrs. Binder,
    thank you for this description of the import of PDF comments. I was interested in any information concerning this new FrameMaker 9 feature because we thought about updating to FrameMaker 9 at our office. This feature will help us in the review workflow substantially.
    Best regards,
    Stefan Moeller
    Germany